Tuesday, January 18, 2011

The End

Our second to last day was defined by relaxation and reflection. Having dealt with a plethora of issues and explored the multitude of sides of Israeli life, we devoted today to purely enjoying the country and each other. In the morning, we went on a gentle hike around Gamla, at the top of the Golan Heights, a few kilometers west of the Syrian border. The site of the beginning of the first Jewish rebellion against the Romans in 67 CE, the area today is an impressive showcase of the beauty of the north of Israel. Overlooking the mountain and the ancient fortifications, we connected to the past directly by understanding that we were the links to the future and through us the memory of the past would live on. Then, we walked the short course to the waterfall, admiring the vultures and other birds of prey that inhabit the valley below.


Back on the bus, we embarked on perhaps the most entertaining hands-on activity of the trip by visiting the De Karina Chocolate Factory located on a kibbutz in the Golan. We watched an educational video about the production of chocolate and then saw first-hand the factory floor, where raw chocolate was melted down and then shaped into all sorts of delicacies including truffles, bars, and pralines. As master chocolatiers skillfully handled the chocolate, we marveled at how this substance which somany of us treasure so greatly, actually goes from bean to consumable form. Then, in a workshop room next door, we got to design our own chocolates, using pre-made shells, chocolate syrup (dark, milk, and white) and raw chocolate. Hibernating artists among us finally got their chance to shine. As we waited for our creations to cool down, we treated ourselves to genuine hot chocolate and stocked up on souvenir goodies.


After lunch, we made our way to the Hamat Hot Springs, where we enjoyed an early evening sulfur bath. Although the smell was difficult for the nostrils, the beneficial properties of the water refreshed and re-energized the many of us who frolicked in the pool. Included was a leisurely dinner and some down time, an opportunity to kick back, talk, and just purely enjoy each other. After a break back at the hotel, we got down to the serious business of reflection, of trying to come to terms of what this trip has meant for us. First, we recalled the places, people and things we had seen. Then we wrote, focusing on the question of what we would bring back with us, of what from this trip would live on in our memories and in our psyches.

“I have gained a greater appreciation for the intricacies of the holy land of Israel. I have explored the wondrous beauty of its cities, deserts, and hills; while also recognizing the harsh realities of Israel and the Middle East. While this experience has not changed my view that Israel cannot be my homeland, I now appreciate the allure that overcomes each Jewish American who makes Aliyah, while I also can clearly identify my serious challenges with Israel. I sometimes struggle to find meaning in Israel, but I still identify myself as a Zionist who strongly supports the democratic and holy ideals of Israel, while also recognizing that Israel cannot survive solely by idealistic aspirations. Overall, Israel is holy place for me, where Judaism is enlightened and where I feel comfortable, safe, and spiritual.”

Iszy Licht


As our trip winds down tomorrow in Tel Aviv, we will be returning to the states, to CJHS, to our regular lives. Fairly soon, the mundane concerns of that world will return and take up our attention and this trip will settle comfortably into the recesses of our memories. But we certainly will not forget it. All the details may not remain clear, but the general impressions, connections, and relationships forged throughout our three weeks in Israel will stay with us, always there, always reminding us of what a great and meaningful time it was, always inspiring us in our future endeavors. We set out on a long journey to discover the hidden sides of Israel not always evident in tourist trips or sightseeing excursions; in the process, we believe we discovered a lot about ourselves and the role that Israel plays in our developing identities. Collectively and individually, each of us is returning home with new insights and new dreams, dramatically affected by our experience. We are grateful to all those that made this possible, and we are thankful to ourselves, each and every one of whom played his or her part in making the Senior Israel Experience what it was. As the culminating event of our CJHS careers, there could not have been a more powerful and transformative way to give meaning to our four years.
Thank you.

Monday, January 17, 2011

A Personal Reflection

"Perhaps my most eye-opening experience occurred today. We arrived in Kiryat Shemona to paint railings, plant trees, and prepare soil for a garden. Rabbi Barkan pulled me aside in the midst of my chalutz-esque labor and led me up some stairs. My initial reaction was to run through a mental list of things he might get me in trouble for. I could lie and tell you I'm perfect and don't ever get into trouble, but perfect sounds rather boring to me.

Anyways, we reached the top of the stairs and came across two men sitting on a bench. One was your typical black-hatter: tzitzit, pe'ot, a suit, the whole nine yards. The second man was a conservative Moroccan Jew who fiddled around with his cigarette. We began discussing (strictly in Hebrew) the values of co-existence, both within Judaism and between Jews and Arabs. The Hasidic Jew quickly refuted my prejudice by pointing out that in Kiryat Shemona, Jews live under one denomination, regardless of their level of observance. Beyond that, in response to Rabbi Barkan's question regarding inter-faith relations, both men smirked. The notion of actually disliking Arabs seemed so foreign to both these men that they asked if Rabbi Barkan was serious.

Their city, brushing up against the Lebanese border, is a constant target of terrorism and its stresses. Yet Rabbi Barkan and I selected two random pedestrians who were among the purest people I have ever met. They gave me an impression of their lives that could not be found in Jerusalem, Tel Aviv, or even a kibbutz. There are no Hasidim, Masorti or Reform Jews in Kiryat Shemona. There are no Arabs either. There are only people, people who believe in God, and more importantly, each other.

In an exaggerated CJHS fashion, those people come together and unconditionally love each other. Their business with God is only between them and God, with no opposition despite the vast spectrum of religious affiliations. Who better to discuss the issue of co-existence than an ultra-orthodox rabbi, a conservative Rabbi, a, with all due respect, scraggly looking, cigarette smoking immigrant, and a teenage boy? The more important question: where else would this happen but Israel?"

Jake Rudolph

Traversing the North

Little is more important to the realization and maintenance of strong group connection and understanding than a little time apart. After an intensive two weeks together, we all went our separate ways to celebrate this past Shabbat. The majority stayed in the environs of Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, others went further afield, but all benefited from time together with family and friends outside the CJHS circle. After minor hiccups (and other bodily functions) we were all re-united on Sunday morning and set our course due north. The final days of our trip will be spent exploring northern Israel and its fascinating history, culture, and geography.


Sunday took us to Givat Haviva, an educational center in the Wadi Ara valley focusing on a variety of concerns including Israeli-Arab co-existence, Arabic language school, and an educational program for the IDF. Our seminar leader Lydia, a Welsh Jew who has lived on a kibbutz in the area for the last forty years, enlightened us with her personal experiences with anti-Semitism in Wales, her decision to make aliyah, and her work over the past decades toward facilitating and promoting understanding between Israeli Jews and Israeli Arabs. The center is located near the Green Line, in an area called the little triangle, which is home to 15,000 Jews and 150,000 Israeli Arabs. We spent a part of the day learning the history and the unique set of circumstances that have faced this rather substantial portion of the Israeli population through many years of conflict, intifadas and peace overtures. As they have struggled to both accept themselves as Israeli citizens and somehow maintain their Arab roots, so we too struggled to understand the effects this reality has had on the development of Israel.



The abstractions of the classroom were powerfully brought to the ground when we visited the Arab village of Barta’a. Immediately following the War of Independence, the Green Line cut this village directly in half, with the eastern half under Jordanian rule and the western half under Israeli rule. Families were literally split apart and the town lived under two governments technically in a state of war with each other. This situation continued for nearly twenty years, when in the wake of the 1967 war, the entire town once again came under Israeli control, with the exception that those in the west were Israeli citizens and those in the east were not. During the intifadas, when the Palestinians in the east participated in the hostilities, their neighbors in the west did not, causing further tensions within this town. After the security fence was constructed, Barta’a was a rare exception when the fence did not run along the Green Line, but rather included the entire town within the Israeli side. Today, the Green Line is literally a ditch that runs through the middle of town. We walked around the village, spoke to some of its inhabitants, tried to get their perspective of things. Overall, it was definitely an eye opening experience of this, yet another, complex side of Israel.


We spent the evening in Kibbutz Hannaton, one of the fledgling kibbutzim of the Conservative (Masorti) movement in Israel. We heard its rabbi speak of the challenges of establishing and maintaining a pluralistic religious institution and share some of our thoughts on the matter. The night concluded on an especially high note as we watched our very own Bears advance over the Seahawks in the playoffs.


The next day took us even further north, to the very border with Lebanon. As we drove next to minefields and looked into the Lebanese countryside, we heard from our new tour guide Nero of the various issues and successes in this part of the country: the historical conflicts of 1982 and 2006, the ongoing conflict with Hizbullah, the success story of draining the swamps and creating fertile agricultural communities, the struggles to extract adequate water from the land, and the natural beauty of the Galilee region. We went on short nature walk through the Banias, an ancient site connected to many peoples and cultures that have made a part of their history in the Middle East (starting with the ancient Israelites, and continuing through the Greeks, Romans, Arabs, and finally the Jews in the modern day). Walking on slightly muddy ground, we weaved and turned our way through this nature park, finally ending up by the beautiful waterfall, where we stopped for pictures.


After a pizza lunch and some reflection, our afternoon was spent in Kiryat Shemona, working with an organization called Ayaleen. Founded by Israeli youth as a national service organization to supplement army service, the program settles young adults in towns and villages throughout the Galilee and the Negev, allowing them to integrate and interact with the surrounding communities. Especially focusing on either underdeveloped areas or those areas suffering from urban decay, these youth aim at revitalizing neighborhoods and making them friendlier, safer places to live. When it came to Kiryat Shemona, the area was suffering from a high crime rate, drug addiction, and a general sense of despair and inability to escape. Within seven years, things have gradually started to turn around and the community is starting to thrive once again. Our students spent time painting fence railings, planting trees, and preparing the soil for a future memorial garden. Contributing directly to the betterment of this community inspired us in many ways and helped us see the vision of a sector of Israeli youth who are dedicated to keeping Israel a vibrant and environmentally aware nation. As evening approached, we drove through Tiberias toward our home for the next two nights at Ohalo Manor, a beautiful hotel overlooking the Sea of Galilee. After a filling dinner and some fun games, we retired for the night, preparing for our second to last day here.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Making Our Way Back Up North

"After a chilly night, we davened, dined, and dashed. Our next stop was the heart-shaped wonder of Machtesh Ramon, a naturally formed crater named for the Romans who used the area as a trade route. Breaking from the expansive wilderness that transformed our last few days, we toured the home of David Ben Gurion, former Prime Minister and champion of the Negev. After discussing the character of Ben Gurion, we sang Hatikva around his gravesite as the sun set over the mountains.


In the evening, we began our brief stay at Mashavei Sadeh with "Refusenik", a documentary detailing the journey of Soviet Jewry. A part of our exploration of the demographic makeup of Israel today, the documentary explained the desires of over 3,000,000 Soviet Jews to leave the USSR, the government's refusal to allow them to, and what it meant to live in such refusal. Our students were suprised to learn of the immense efforts of world's Jewry to free the Soviet Jews, especially in the United States.


As we finished our last full day in the south, the bond forged between the group and the land became even more apparent. Nearly all of us have been to Israel before, and each time we are asked if we "connected". For many, answering in the affirmative was a way of appeasing expectant teachers or group leaders. It seemed like what we were supposed to say. This time, there was a shift. The individuals in the class of 2011 seemed to truly find something in the desolate beauty of the sandstone and granite, something powerful and inexplicable. We want to stay in touch with this place, by means physical or cognitive. This blogger has a feeling we will all find a way to do so."

Aliza Small


After waking up in our luxurious lodgings and davening, we piled onto the bus and continued our drive north to the development town of Yeruham. Founded in the early 1950s, it was one of the many such towns designed to accommodate the sudden influx of Jews Israel experienced in the first decade of its existence. The task of absorbing the DPs, the emigrating Jewish refugees from the Middle East, and all others eager to make the new state their home was challenging: the population literally more than doubled and all those people needed jobs, places to live, and the attendant infrastructure. Israel engaged in a decade of building. One solution was to develop the Negev, with many towns springing up from the ground and constructing all the appropriate buildings. Schools, hospitals, houses and apartments, stores, community centers, synagogues. Many of these towns still stand today and are struggling in their self-definition in the 21st century. The same problems that accompanied their founding are no longer as relevant, so they in some ways are socio-economic dinosaurs, not attracting the residents and the investment to make the community thrive.


We discovered this by walking the streets, interviewing the people, getting of glimpse of this, yet another way of life in Israel. What we discovered surprised us. While many expressed the traditional stereotype of “wanting to escape this dead end town,” some expressed their love for it and defended their decisions to raise their families here. We visited a community center, a technology building, and a school and understood a little bit more about this side of Israel. We concluded our time in Yerucham by making paper kites and drawing our “visions for the future” on them. Flying the kites, with some soaring high and others failing to make flight, we learned relevant lessons about the need to persevere with certain visions, the need to drop or step aside with others.


We left Yerucham and made our way for the heart of modern Israel, Tel Aviv. A modern metropolis in the Middle East, the city boasts a big population and has everything a modern city should have. As we get ready for dinner and our outing at a play performed by the deaf and blind, we also prepare for our Free Weekend, where our students will stay with friends or relatives throughout Israel.


Although our time here is gradually drawing to a close, there is still plenty left. We wish you a wonderful upcoming Shabbat and will return on Sunday with new updates. Kol tuv.


r




24 Hours in the Desert

"For some, the desert is a place of clear skies and deep breaths. Not so for our seven brave warriors of mild sickness, who were held back at beautiful Kibbutz Ketura for some much needed r&r. Staying with them was our incomparable blog master, Mr. Marchenko. Many thanks to him for his beautiful blogging thus far! His brief hiatus will end shortly.


After a lovely breakfast, we left Kibbutz Ketura and made our way to Yutvata for some famously delicious dairy. Our stomachs filled (perhaps inconveniently), we set out for the 24-Hour Desert Experience.


As the expanse of land became more majestically desolate, the presence of kibbutzim dwindled. 6 miles north of Eilat and flanked by visible Egypt and Jordan, we arrived at our campsite and found it expertly set up by Avia and Ofer, the unofficial nature brigade.


Ofer served as our teacher for the excursion. Standing above a section of the Syrio-African rift, we were taught to locate ourselves on the planet. At the tip of the crossroads between Africa and Asia, our place in the world became both clear and minuscule.


Armed with mind-boggling geography, we began the day's hike. Beforehand, it was described as a nice ambling path, looping through canyons and impressive mountain views. The scenery was indeed wonderful, but the incline of the wadi left many with sore legs. Still, the ongoing lessons in desert geology and botany was well worth it. at many points, the port city of Aqaba was visible over the hills, reminding us just how close we were to Israel's southernmost point.



Post-hike, we returned to the camp for some tent arranging, down time, and a good 'ol pot of camping soup. Some students took time to wander down the mountain paths, exploring the rocky plateaus and miniature canyons of the Negev as the sun set. We then gathered for dinner by the fire, prepared by the staff and students. Stomachs full and shoes dusty, the students participated in a stealthy game of capture the flag by moonlight, sneaking like ibex through inch-high brush and perilous stones.



The temperature dropped steadily as the moon rose higher. Bundled up around the fire, Ishai, our madrich, taught everyone how to identify constellations and spot Polaris. Following the crash course in astronomy, the true spirit of our grade emerged once again. As the flames turned to embers, we reflected on transitions and the courses of our lives. Just as we sat at the crossroads of tectonic plates, countries, and continents, so too do we stand at a crossroads of our respective life journeys.



Though the fire died and the winds picked up, we dozed off still contemplating. The gorgeous silence that permeated our surroundings will stay with us for quite awhile. Artistic credit for this blog entry goes to oseh ma'aseh breishit"

Aliza Small

Monday, January 10, 2011

"Kibbutzniks"

In the itinerary, this morning’s first event was described simply: “hike to mountain overlook for tefillah.” But it failed to do justice to the majesty that we encountered. Following a narrow, windy, and rocky path, we made our way out of the kibbutz and into the mountains of the Negev. Harrowing at points, gently sloping at others, we ascended a series of peaks while the beautiful vista expanded around us. Each time we arrive at an apparent peak, thinking we had arrived, gigantic chunks of the mountains were revealed to us. This happened literally three times, but we finally arrived at the top and overlooked the Arava Valley below us to the east and the continuation of the Negev to the west. Many have tried but few have been capable of describing the stunning natural beauty of the mountains and the valleys of this region. As we began davening, many thoughts turned to Moses and Sinai and the conditions faced on that mountain. Looking out, if we for a second imagined that the road was not there, nor the green leafy patch of the kibbutz, the landscape cannot have changed much over the past couple of thousand years. As we learned, the Arava valley, which forms the natural border between Jordan and Israel in the south, sits on the Afro-Syrian ridge, where two tectonic plates meet and are apparently rubbing against each other (to the point that over the last 19 million years, the land of Israel and the land of Jordan have been moving in opposite directions, around 150 kilometers, to be exact). But with human settlement here, the view was similar to that beheld by the ancient Israelites, and davening in this space, high above the earth and nature’s glory was a sacred experience. The way down, while quicker, was far scarier because we were constantly looking down at the ground far, far away. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uAyygi_Ecz8



After an al fresco breakfast outside, we learned about efforts on the kibbutz to introduce organic farming to Israel. While some strides have been made, Israel still lags behind in these efforts compared to the United States. Nonetheless, more and more Israelis are becoming interested in growing and buying produce certified as organic and there are movements within the so-called eco-kosher community to bring together kashrut and organic ideologies. At Ketura, the community organic garden is still quite small and there are no plans for commercial organic farming as of yet, but there is an educational component to it, as well as hands on. We mulched in the vegetable garden and weeded the flower one.



After lunch and some down time, we boarded the bus and headed back out to the Negev. Ascending up out of the Arava valley, we entered a lonely stretch of road, surrounded by the hilly and rocky desert on both sides. Stopping seemingly in the middle of nowhere, we got off the bus with nothing but vast expanse on either side of us, with an Air Force base and the Sinai deep in the horizon to the west. After another minor trek upwards, we ascended a peak where we found the famous Negev sand dunes. We took off our shoes and socks and enjoyed a good hour in the finest, softest sand almost anywhere on the planet. Careening down the hill, then scrambling up for more, it was a physical yet extremely entertaining time. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zp1Y5lmGdBw



What followed was perhaps one of the most meaningful experiences of the trip, if not entire lifetimes.


As the sun set to the west, we separated, each individual finding a spot of solitude in the dunes, looking out at the seemingly infinite stretch of mountains and desert. Sitting, alone, we were left to our thoughts, our feelings, cut off from everything but ourselves and the majestic power of the earth. For a good hour, we sat, reflected, interrupted only briefly by the sound of the shofar to let us know it was time to write about our experience. In the process, the remaining light of the day faded, as twilight descended on the desert in the light of the infant moon. After days and days of interactions and engagement with others and ourselves, suddenly, swiftly all that was removed. In an instant, we were transported into a timeless, eternal world that has not changed for millions of years, vigilantly standing still through night and day, winter and summer, war and peace. The power of the land truly took hold of our imaginations here.


Afterwards, around the campfire and over s’mores, we shared our experiences. To some, it was about beholding the immenseness of the universe, of feeling really small in a really large space, surrounded by billions of stars and galaxies, each with their own story to tell. To others, it was about the transformative silence, the most incredible silence there is: total to the point that paper falling to the ground or pencil writing on paper were literally deafening. And in that silence, in that tranquility, was an incredible connection to the past, to the present, to ancestors, and, most importantly, to a universal feeling of peace. Some described it as the ultimate act of solitude, an entrĂ©e to a live show of the cosmos unfolding. Still others referred to the overpowering loneliness, both physical and emotional, that overtook them and refused to let go. Some literally cried in a cathartic cleansing, while others mentioned the obvious and undeniable removal from the monotony and routine of patterned life. For some, although being in Israel for the 7th time, it was only on this trip, and especially during this experience, that they realized a true connection to the country and a true love of the land. And finally, perhaps most importantly, the most commonly expressed feeling was one of connection between the students, of the veritable and tangible love that exists after years and years of knowing, trusting, and engaging with each other. Hearing student after student express this emotion lifted the spirits of the entire group above and beyond. As the fire began to die out and the stars, infinite in number, penetrated our consciousness, something nearly miraculous happened. Without a plan or announcement or warning, one by one the students began rising, standing shoulder to shoulder. As others realized what was happening, they too joined, without a single word, until finally the circle became complete, and we, a small group in the middle of a vast desert, formed an unbreakable whole, cemented by song. That singular memory will live in our hearts and minds forever. In fact, our guide David from the kibbutz, in all earnestness, told us that out of the hundreds of trips to the desert that he has conducted in his life, he has never, ever seen what he saw tonight --- the reflections, the insights, and the communal bond that holds together this unique and wonderful group of students. If there was ever a higher purpose to this trip, we found it tonight.



Back on the bus, back on the kibbutz, we ate a barbecue dinner and retired for the night, having rediscovered this beautiful connection between ourselves. Tonight we shall sleep like kings.

Sunday, January 9, 2011

Down South

In a strange twist, the Jerusalem skies darkened with rain as we made our way to four different shuls for Shabbat services only to clear up for a wonderful evening of dinner and relaxation. Shabbat presented us with a great opportunity to re-charge, re-focus and resume our experience.


Early this morning, with bags packed, we boarded the bus, powered up the iPod, and began the long scenic drive south. The hills of Jerusalem, packed as they are with buildings and structures, gradually were replaced by the rolling Judean hills as we made our way out of the city and into the open country. From the bus, the mountains themselves seemed to be moving, swaying as if waves in an ocean, stretching back as far as the eye could see. Beautiful mounds, blending into each other, reminded us that this land is not just one of religious and cultural beauty but of immense natural beauty as well. The stones, rocks, and formations, in themselves not so complex, came together to create a vivid and stirring image. Seamlessly, far off at first, the road wound its way nearer to the Dead Sea; with ears popping, we had descended a whopping kilometer and a half below Jerusalem to reach the lowest point on planet Earth. The majestic power of the water merited a quick stop to say hello and take some pictures, and we were on our way again, swaying rhythmically to the beats of the bus. Driving past Massada but not stopping was a welcome reminder that we are not tourists here and have a more important mission.


Our home for the next two days will be Kibbutz Ketura, located half hour north of Eilat, in the middle of the Negev. As we pulled in, we witnessed the powerful vistas of the Jordanian mountains to the east and the Negev mountains to the west, and sandwiched in between, the expanse of the desert and the buildings of the kibbutz. Our experience of communal living started with hearing a lecture from a professor at the Arava Institute, a college located on the premises of the kibbutz that specializes in environmental research. Among its many endeavors is exploring renewable energy resources, whether through photovoltaic cells, biomass recycling, or hydrogen-boron automobile technology. Offering degrees in renewable energy and bringing together Israeli Jews, Israeli Arabs, Jordanian Arabs, and non-Middle Eastern students, the Institute is one of a kind in that it promotes co-existence through engaging in studies devoted for future sustainability. Many students responded to this newly acquired knowledge with desires to spend significant time at this kibbutz during their college years. Afterwards, standing at a symbolic spot of a bunker from the 1967 war we appreciated just how much has happened since then by looking at the future home of the first solar power plant in Israel and the thousands of boxes holding the solar cells. Knowing that Israel is at the forefront of research and technology of this type is a comforting experience.


Our evening was spent on the waterfront promenade at Eilat, taking in the sights, sounds, and tasty delicacies of this resort town. With three hours of free time, we had a wonderful opportunity to get a full sense of this town, some of us even choosing to go to great heights… http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4FLICK0H8zI


We returned to the kibbutz and heard from a panel of current kibbutz residents, all our age, who discussed the beauty, challenge, and reward of living on kibbutz. The fundamental difference of communal life from the kind of life we are all used to was compelling and insightful to behold. Composed of some 150 permanent members and 350 part-time residents, these kibbutzniks have chosen to forsake private property and personal income (two fundamental realities of the modern world) and instead engage in a cooperative enterprise aimed at creating a better life for themselves. Whether through the aforementioned Institute or through the dairy farm or through a specialized algae growth and processing facility (which produces a special anti-aging product commonly found in health foods, medicines, and cosmetics), all are engaged in meaningful work for the sake of collective, not individual success. Many are raising their families here, teaching timeless and essential values that often fall away in the world outside. Spending a couple of days here will definitely teach us an alternative viewpoint on life and we definitely look forward to seeing where it will take us.